Neighbour’s Fence Feud Leaves 95-Year-Old Widow With £1 Million Legal Bill

0
Neighbour’s Fence Feud Leaves 95-Year-Old Widow With £1 Million Legal Bill

A 95-year-old widow has been left to pay more than £1 million in legal fees after losing an appeal over costs in a nearly decade-long boundary dispute with her neighbours.

The High Court dismissed Mrs Egan’s bid to make Mr and Mrs Morgan pay her costs, despite condemning Mr Morgan’s language toward lawyers, judges and court staff as “deplorable and unacceptable.”

The dispute concerned a roughly 60-metre strip of grass, trees and scrub between neighbouring multimillion-pound properties in Sissinghurst, Kent. The Morgans own Sissinghurst Court, a 17th-century timber-framed house.

According to Mrs Egan’s barrister, Daniel Petrides, the trouble began in September 2015 when the Morgans cut through an existing wooden fence and installed posts on land she owned without consulting her.

Her solicitors demanded that the posts be removed. Petrides said the Morgans later removed them, bulldozed the existing fence and erected another one. Mrs Egan’s lawyers offered to let that fence remain under certain conditions, but the disagreement continued and she eventually had it taken down.

The Morgans then commissioned a permanent fence with concrete posts and sued Mrs Egan over the destruction of the previous fence, seeking compensation for materials and labour. Litigation followed in 2016.

 

During the dispute, Mr Morgan called a lawyer a “lying hypocritical devious arse.” Mrs Egan’s legal team said he had also described her as “malevolent,” “frankly poisonous” and “all-knowing self-appointed royalty.”

Her barrister argued that she had been the real winner in the litigation and that the abusive conduct warranted an order requiring the Morgans to pay her legal costs on the more generous indemnity basis.

Mr Justice Tappin dismissed her appeal against the earlier costs decision. He said the dispute had consumed time, money and energy “wholly out of proportion” to the financial value of the land involved.

Mrs Egan had employed lawyers throughout and reported spending more than £1 million. The Morgans incurred a six-figure bill, despite representing themselves for much of the proceedings.

The couple said their purpose had been to replace a fallen fence and keep their pets from escaping.

“This wasn’t about money. It never was,” they said. “We put a fence up where there had always been a fence.”

The ruling leaves Mrs Egan responsible for her own seven-figure legal bill.


 

About Post Author