Florida Couple Gave a Nissan Dealer One Star. They Say the Manager Went After Their Family Business.

0
Florida Couple Gave a Nissan Dealer One Star. They Say the Manager Went After Their Family Business.

A Florida couple says a one-star review over transmission trouble in their new Nissan van prompted the dealership’s general manager to leave a bad review of their family upholstery shop and recruit others to do the same.

The couple said the van developed serious transmission problems shortly after they bought it. Frustrated with the dealership’s response, they posted a review describing what happened. In a social media video that drew about 1.4 million views, the wife said the manager responded by giving their upholstery shop a low rating and asking people he knew to leave negative reviews.

Critical reviews soon appeared on the dealership’s own listings. The family-owned dealer group acknowledged that a manager had responded inappropriately, said it had apologized directly to the couple and pledged company-wide ethics training. The statement gave no details about formal discipline.

The general manager posted a separate apology and said he would take time away from the dealership to reflect on his conduct. The couple urged viewers to leave dealership employees who had no part in the dispute alone.

How Florida and Japan handle vehicle complaints

Florida’s lemon law can provide a refund or replacement for qualifying new vehicles with defects that remain unresolved after reasonable repair attempts. For buyers dealing with a recurring transmission problem, dated repair orders, diagnostic codes and records of conversations with the dealer can help establish what went wrong and how many chances the dealer had to fix it.

In Japan, Nissan generally offers a new-vehicle warranty of three years or 60,000 kilometers (about 37,000 miles) and separate coverage for key components, including the engine and transmission, for five years or 100,000 kilometers (about 62,000 miles). Each warranty ends when the first limit is reached, and terms can vary by model. Owners can bring their repair records to the automaker’s customer service department or call Japan’s consumer hotline at 188 for a referral to a local consumer affairs office.

Japan also has criminal laws that can apply to some online attacks. Public defamation and obstruction of a business through false rumors or fraudulent means can each carry up to three years in custody or a fine of up to ¥500,000. Public insult is a separate offense carrying up to one year in custody or a fine of up to ¥300,000. Whether any of those laws applies depends on what was posted and the circumstances.

The dealership and its manager apologized after the review dispute went viral. It remains unclear whether the couple’s van was repaired.


About Post Author