City dismisses Iryna Zarutska murder lawsuit

0
City dismisses Iryna Zarutska murder lawsuit

The North Carolina city of Charlotte sparked anger this week by filing a motion to dismiss a lawsuit from the family of Iryna Zarutska.

Zarutska was fatally stabbed while aboard a light rail train in August 2025 by a repeat homeless offender with an extensive criminal record who had been arrested 14 times before the attack.

After her death, Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, filed a suit against both the city and its transit security company, Professional Security Services, according to The Charlotte Observer.

In the complaint, he alleged that his niece’s death was preventable and that both Charlotte and Professional Security Services had been aware of the safety issues aboard the city’s light rail, but had done nothing.

Charlotte and its security service company “were responsible for protecting lawful passengers from known and foreseeable dangers,” the lawsuit reads.

“Their failures caused the fatal stabbing.”

In a motion filed on Monday in the Mecklenburg County Superior Court, the city acknowledged the circumstances surrounding Zarutska’s death but denied that it was responsible.

“The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by Decarlos Brown Jr.,” city attorneys wrote, according to The Charlotte Observer. “The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack.”

According to The North Carolina Beat, the city also admitted that Brown, the man accused of stabbing Zarutska, had been allowed to board the light rail without presenting a pass or ticket.

However, the city denied that Brown’s lack of payment had made his subsequent attack on Zarutska foreseeable.

The city attorneys further cited government immunity by making the case that it protects Charlotte’s government from wrongful death claims related to core city functions like the deployment of law enforcement.

The attorneys also asked that, in case the dismissal isn’t approved, any potential judgment against the city be limited to under $1 million.

The city’s move appeared to anger many, including Townhall senior reporter Amy Curtis, who noted in a social media post that the city had no qualms about recently settling a $1.7 million lawsuit filed by protesters who had participated in the oftentimes violent 2020 Black Lives Matter “protests.”

However, Charlotte station WSOC-TV reporter Joe Bruno argued on social media that Charlotte had also asked for that suit to be dismissed before bending the knee and agreeing to a payout.

Meanwhile, Allen Mashburn, a North Carolina pastor and conservative commentator who ran for lieutenant governor of North Carolina in 2024, angrily called Charlotte a “third-rate city” in a social media post.

And finally, former West Virginia state House Del. Derrick Evans called out Charlotte for trying to claim immunity.

“Are they seriously going from claim immunity or claim they did all they could do?” he wrote on social media. “Get serious. This is unbelievable.”

–

Sick development in Iryna Zarutska saga as city moves to dismiss case entirely

About Post Author