She Lost the Miss USA Crown in a Day. Nearly 70 Years Later, a New Winner Is Telling Her Story.

0
She Lost the Miss USA Crown in a Day. Nearly 70 Years Later, a New Winner Is Telling Her Story.

Mary Leona Gage had barely had time to wear the Miss USA crown when pageant officials took it away. She had won in Long Beach, California, on July 18, 1957, as Miss Maryland. By the next day, officials had learned she was married and had two sons. She had also told them she was 21. She was actually 18.

Nearly seven decades later, another Miss USA headed to an international pageant wearing Gage’s portrait. Justus Kelley, a 31-year-old married woman and foster mother of two, wore a custom black-and-white coat by TTON Couture as she left for Puerto Rico. Gage’s image was printed across the shoulders.

Kelley told People that preparing to represent the United States at Miss Universe made her think about the woman who briefly had that same chance. Gage had to keep her family life a secret to compete. Kelley had talked openly about hers on the way to winning the crown.

A crown that lasted about 24 hours

Born in Longview, Texas, Gage had married at 14 and had her second child by 16. She later said she entered the Maryland pageant hoping it would lead to modeling work. After winning Miss USA, she told reporters she didn’t even have a boyfriend. The story unraveled within a day, and the title went to runner-up Charlotte Sheffield of Utah.

Losing the crown brought Gage a burst of publicity, but the episode remained a source of mixed feelings, her son later told the Los Angeles Times. She died in 2010 at 71.

What changed for Kelley

Miss USA began allowing married women and mothers to compete in 2023. Kelley, who represented Virginia, won the national pageant in Miami on Aug. 27. She became the first openly married mother to win and keep the title, and the first Miss USA winner over 30. A philanthropic adviser and licensed foster parent, she founded Foster Footprints to support children and families involved in foster care.

Kelley is scheduled to represent the United States at the 75th Miss Universe competition on Nov. 24 at the Coliseo de Puerto Rico José Miguel Agrelot in San Juan. She wore the coat on her way there, giving Gage a moment in the spotlight ahead of the competition she never got to enter.

 


About Post Author