An Idaho attorney has scored his second courtroom victory against his homeowners association over an elaborate Christmas light display — and he’s celebrating by buying even more decorations.
Jeremy Morris, a lawyer known locally as the “Christmas Lawyer,” has been locked in a long-running legal battle with his former HOA over a festive holiday display at his home. What began as a dispute over Christmas lights turned into years of litigation that ultimately cost the HOA far more than it ever stood to gain.
Morris first prevailed in court in 2019, when a judge awarded him $75,000 after ruling in his favor. Rather than letting the matter end there, the HOA appealed the decision and continued fighting the case through multiple levels of the court system. Morris estimates the association spent close to $1 million in legal fees trying to overturn the ruling.
GRINCH PAYS UP: Idaho lawyer Jeremy Morris tells Fox News Digital that he settled with his HOA for significantly more than the original $75,000 jury award after years of legal battles — and he’s spending the money on even more holiday decorations.
“I’m buying a lot of Christmas… pic.twitter.com/LHWAFtL1M0
— Fox News (@FoxNews) December 24, 2025
The dispute resurfaced again when the case made its way to the Supreme Court, which sent it back to a lower appellate court. Shortly afterward, the HOA agreed to a settlement — marking Morris’s second major legal win in the saga and resulting in an even larger financial payout.
According to FOX News Digital, Morris’s holiday display wasn’t just decorative. It also helped raise money for childhood cancer causes, making the HOA’s objections even more controversial.
Now that the case is finally over, Morris says he knows exactly how he’ll use the settlement money.
“I’m buying a lot of Christmas lights,” he said. “And I enjoy it every time I screw in a light bulb. I think of my HOA and their effort to shut down Christmas.”
Supporters say the outcome could have been avoided entirely if the HOA had chosen compromise over confrontation. Instead, the association pursued years of costly litigation — and lost twice.
In the end, Morris walked away victorious, and Christmas cheer prevailed.